
[Sent across four days, 04-26 to 04-29, to split into 1500 character pieces.]
When I asked. During a session, Tim explained a weird thing, something he’s into at the moment, a genre called bardcore. Popular songs recreated with 17th century instruments. Lots of flutes, lots of lutes, no percussion.
How I went to listen. I found a best of list. Not sure the quality of the list maker, but I checked many song titles that I recognized and know that I enjoy.
Listening, I started to imagine a bizarre, unrealistic locale. I was standing among a small crowd in a medieval bar. The kegs of mead or ale dripping slowly. Someone absentmindedly catching the seeping. The room had several long log benches, a low stage, a chamber consort playing. I liked what I heard. But I couldn’t get inside. Something was missing, or something I needed to find was just out of reach. Not incomplete exactly. Something pointing at something without being realized. There’s something there that is irritating, and I can’t listen to very much.
The absence of percussion is part of the unrest. There’s no anchor. No beat to ground the sound. I kept waiting for something to arrive and it never did. That restlessness—the reaching toward something that keeps dissolving. I don’t get it. And I hate that I don’t get it. And underneath the hate is something quieter—the feeling that not getting it means something about me. That I’m missing whatever it takes to be someone who gets it. The ghost of a feeling. The hint without the thing itself.
I looked around at the crowd. They were confused and transfixed. The chamber consort doesn’t stop; playing song after song; the endless play is as disturbing as the unusual unfamiliar—unreachable. I had the advantage of knowing there was a different version. They seemed to be caught in a grand tease of being given something that had much more available, just not now. And not even in their lifetime. I feel incredibly sad, because I can change the channel and go back to the original versions of the songs.
Slam poetry does the same thing. Different mechanism, same feeling. The rhythm and the harshness and the pauses all point toward something I can’t locate. Something there, irritating, unreachable. I heard slam poetry for the first time at a WriteCamp in Milwaukee and didn’t get that artwork, then, either. I’ve experimented with writing my own slam poetry to see if I can reverse engineer something similar.
I attended the Candlelight: Coldplay & Imagine Dragons concert—hits from both bands reimagined by string quartet: two violins, viola, cello—tolerable. Like bardcore, no percussion, no anchor beat. Unlike bardcore, familiar songs gave the ear something to hold. Enough to follow, not enough to want again. Maybe it should have been obvious bardcore wasn’t part of my music appreciation.
At my request, Tim offered a glimpse of who he is outside the office. One thing he likes. I went looking for him in his music and couldn’t get there. It makes me sad that I can’t listen to the bardcore, because I’m trying to figure out what he likes and who he is. It just makes me sad that it’s like, “Oh, this is one thing he told me he likes, and I listened, and I’m like, I don’t get it.”
There is a Kevin parallel. This has happened before. When I was having my exit interview after Kevin stopped being my personal trainer, sitting in a coffee shop, I asked him about his favorite music. I jotted down a small list of the bands he told me. One from the list: Bullet For My Valentine. Later I listened to samples of all the bands on the list and I didn’t get it. I didn’t see it in him or him in it, and it made me so sad. I actually fought hard to find just one song I liked by the artists.
Unsurprisingly, there is a personal pattern. A decade ago, one day at Tai Chi, Brendan talked about going to see two bands locally. The Pines and The Weepies—I can tolerate them when I pull them into Apple Music, even appreciate them a little, but they don’t call to me. They’re part of Brendan’s music library, not mine. Well, they are in there, just rarely sought out.
It’s not just Tim. It’s not just Kevin. It’s a rhythm I keep stepping into. The same kind of emotion again. Makes me feel like asking specific people what kind of music they like is almost pointless then.
I now have multiple examples that it doesn’t get me anything. A pattern—asking what music someone loves and finding myself on the outside. The same kind of sad over and over again. Perhaps, addicted to a certain kind of sadness.
I recall seeing some suspended bead art installations—the kind where scattered pieces only cohere into an image from one specific vantage point—is what this feels like made visible. You move slightly and the image dissolves. You move back and it almost returns.
Music is supposed to be universal. A bridge. A way in. And yet, I keep asking. I go looking for people in their music, hoping to find connection—and each time, I come back empty. The pattern is clear now. It’s not accidental. The music they love feels just as unreachable as they are.
And still, I ask.








